Volunteers

Stop the Volunteer Revolving Door

Stop the Volunteer Revolving Door

Author

Mark Crooks

A person struggling to carry an unstable high stack of loose paper
A person struggling to carry an unstable high stack of loose paper

The willingness is there. It's the culture asking everything of them that's broken.

When did experience replace pay?

Nobody would take a job that pays in exposure. Unless it's at church, where we call it ministry.

It sounds holy. It started holy. But over time the sentiment curdled. What began as generosity became a status system. The more you serve and the less you receive, the higher you rank. Worth gets measured in hours logged instead of joy. People start finding their identity in what they do rather than in why they do it.

And here is the quiet contradiction. It is not easy to ask for help. Most of us wrestle with it. Yet in church we expect it constantly from the congregation, as if the whole thing runs on guilt and good intentions.

The numbers back this up. Lifeway Research found that 86% of churchgoers say they want to serve people in their community, but only 30% volunteered for any charity in the past year. The desire is there. The culture is not.

To be clear, the theology underneath is right. The body of Christ should function as a body. Everyone coming together, serving one another. The problem is not the teaching. The problem is that we teach it and leave it there. No specifics. No boundaries. Just serve more, receive less.

Go back to Acts 4 and look at the first church. They shared what they had. They met each other's needs. It was the building of a community meant to last forever, not a machine that consumed people to keep running. That is the picture. Somewhere we swapped it for a rota.

The culture needs to change. Serving is not working without end. Boundaries are not unspiritual. And rewards are not bribery. They are recognition that what someone gives actually matters.

So leaders, when you ask for volunteers, do the work the asking requires.

Be clear about the responsibility. Name the time and the effort before anyone signs up. Vague asks produce vague commitment, and vague commitment burns people out. As Carey Nieuwhof puts it, few things are more demotivating than giving up your time as a volunteer only to discover nobody set you up to succeed.

Be collaborative and protective as volunteers step into ministry. Walk with them. Do not hand them a task and disappear.

Reward them in proportion to the role. Let the role build them up, not break them down.

Affirm them, privately and publicly. Tell volunteers they are doing well, and mean it. Recognition is not flattery. It is fuel. ChurchTechToday notes that most volunteers leave because they feel overlooked or burned out, and consistent recognition builds trust.

Protect their time. They have other responsibilities, other callings, families, jobs, rest. Treat their hours at church as what they are: an offering to God. Do not spend someone else's offering carelessly.

And here is the harder word. Do not be like the sons of Eli, who took the offering meat for themselves before the fat was burned. They took what was meant for God and spent it on themselves. When leaders consume volunteer labour to feed the machine, it is the same old sin in new clothes.

Do not be cheap, either. If a role needs full-time commitment, do not patch it together with five exhausted volunteers. You can honour someone with money. If they are giving their working life to the church, pay them accordingly.

And stop calling experience a reward when it is all you offer. Experience is only a reward if it is what the volunteer actually wants. Otherwise it is just a nicer word for unpaid labour.

Instead, create openings for people to step into ministry with their passion and their gifts. The church should nurture volunteers, help them discover what they carry, and let them lead from it. A volunteer serving from passion will outlast ten serving from obligation. Barna's State of the Church research found weekly church volunteering has rebounded past pre-COVID levels, with Gen Z and Millennials leading the way. The willingness is there.

Your volunteers are not the problem. The culture asking everything of them might be.

Bibliography

Related Posts

Fridge outside a public park with magnets and paper pinned to it
Digital Hospitality
Digital Hospitality

Long exporsure shot of a few cameras floating down a river
Sunday Systems
Sunday Systems

Want to join the Canopy?

One thoughtful note a month. Rest, craft, ministry plus first looks at new Garden templates. Unsubscribe anytime, no hard feelings.

Day Seven Primary logo

Creative design for the work of ministry.

A church-focused creative studio for branding, websites, slides and thoughtful resources.

Day Seven Primary logo

Creative design for the work
of ministry.

A church-focused creative studio for branding, websites, slides and thoughtful resources.

Day Seven Primary logo

Creative design for the work
of ministry.

A church-focused creative studio for branding, websites, slides and thoughtful resources.